POP Idol reject Andrew Derbyshire today backed the show's Mr Nasty Simon Cowell - and told MPs to stay out of the row over the cutting comments of the competition's judges.

A group of angry MPs - including East Lancashire's Gordon Prentice - have launched a stinging attack on the judging panel of the hit TV show, who have reduced some contenders to tears with their criticisms.

But Padiham lad Andrew, who reached the final 50 in 2001, said: "It's part of the show!"

Pendle Labour backbencher Mr Prentice and his 11 colleagues have put down an official Parliamentary motion condemning the judges for their "irresponsible" comments and calling on them to consider hopefuls' talent, not just looks.

The MPs' Early Day motion on the Commons Order paper sent to all ministers, MPs and senior civil servants said: "We condemn the irresponsible comments of the so-called music experts on this programme when passing their judgements on the young performers. Pressurising young people, and women in particular, to conform to fit the mould sends out the wrong message not only to the participants but to other talented youngsters who may also have aspirations to progress in the music industry.

"We further believe that contestants should be judged solely on their unique singing talents and not on pre-conceived images and therefore call on the self-appointed image makers to break the mould that could be denying those who enjoy listening to quality music that opportunity."

Andrew, 21, who is currently performing in a production of the musical, Joseph, in Cardiff, is also working with Brian May to launch his own music career early next year. He said: "The nasty comments are all part of the show. Simon Cowell is actually a really nice person.

"People do have feelings but the comments are the reason that people tune into the show.But if people want success so badly then they can probably take the criticism."

Simon Cowell hit back at MP'sby saying they have made "sweeping generalisations." He said: "I thought the Labour Party was supposed to be a party of free enterprise. I'm sorry my earnings upset them."