News RSS Feed


Probe into Accrington pensioner's death after bailiff visit over speeding fine


A PENSIONER collapsed and died from a heart attack after being taken to a cashpoint by a bailiff to pay an overdue speeding fine.

Justice Minister and Blackburn MP Jack Straw has ordered court bosses to launch an investigation into the death of retired pub landlord Andy Miller.

The family of Mr Miller, 78, of Accrington, have told of their anger that a bailiff was sent to his house, saying it would have put him under ‘incredible duress’.

Mr Miller had been released from a two-month stay in hospital a fortnight before after suffering a heart attack at Ewood Park before a Blackburn Rovers game.

His son, Mick, 48, said the family had written to the court to explain why Mr Miller had not paid the overdue £60 speeding fine for an offence committed on the M55.

But Blackpool magistrates still gave permission for the bailiff to go to his home in India Street, Accrington.

The court also added on £290 to what Mr Miller owed in court costs.

The official went round on January 7 and asked Mr Miller, a former landlord of the Cabin End pub in Knuzden, to visit a cashpoint and pay the fine, his family said.

Father-of-five Mr Miller was driven to Accrington town centre. The bailiff parked up and waited for Mr Miller, but he collapsed in Union Street before he reached a cashpoint.

Coroner Michael Singleton has ruled out an inquest, because tests had found Mr Miller died of natural causes as a result of heart problems, officials said.

His son Mick said he wanted answers from court bosses as their letter told them his father was suffering from memory loss and confusion.

Mick, who lives in Lower Darwen, said: “Bailiffs should not be allowed to behave like this.

“Dad was put under incredible duress.

“I know how nervous he had been and what a strain this would have been on him.”

Mr Miller’s nephew Steve Flanigan, 61, added: ”He was by himself when it happened. I can’t help but think that if I had been there it would have been a very different story.

“The visit must have been such a shock, because most people don’t know what their rights are. When someone is there on your doorstep, can you just tell them to go away? Do you have to do what they say? Most people just wouldn’t know.”

Police said CCTV cameras showed Mr Miller walking alone to various points in the town centre, shortly before he collapsed.

Officers who had been patrolling nearby were at his side within minutes and attempted to resuscitate him. Police later interviewed the bailiff, who made himself known to officers.

Sergeant Graham Brownsmith said it was ‘clearly a tragic incident’.

Greg Pope, Hyndburn MP, said he was so concerned by the case that he brought it to the attention of Mr Straw who ordered the investigation.

He said: “There are many things about this case which require an answer. Why didn't the court service take into account that Mr Miller was in poor health? There needs to be some sort of answer to that question and I hope the court service will come forward and do that.”

A spokesman for the Her Majesty's Courts Service said they could not comment fully due to the investigation but added: “We would like to offer our sincere condolences to Mr Miller’s family. We will report back to them.”

Mr Straw: "Greg Pope got in touch with me and we have arranged for an investigation to take place. We await the outcome."

Mr Miller’s family said that before his illness he had been suffering money problems - which they believe may have been why he had not paid the speeding fine - and had been working as a cleaner in a bid to make ends meet.

After a heart attack on October 25, the former Blackburn town centre, Barrow and Knuzden pub landlord suffered a stroke and was in a coma for 10 days.

He was allowed home on Christmas Eve, his birthday, to spend the festive season with his family.

Comments(27)

Nad says...
9:41am Fri 16 Jan 09

Disggusting actions by the court service AND the Coroner Michael Singleton.
An inquest needs to be held and these faceless mandarins who gave the go ahead for the Bailiff visit brought to book.
The attitude and actions of the Bailiff, ie. what was the tone of the conversation when he spoke to Mr Miller, need examining also.

Condolences to Mr. millers Family and I hope you get your inquest Mick. Keep up the pressure for your Dads sake.

The Lancs says...
9:50am Fri 16 Jan 09

Shame on the system that has allowed this elderly gentleman to be treated worse than a common criminal. This is nothing other than legalised extortion. Why is there no facility to allow those who find themselves subject to a speeding fine to pay in installments if they have financial difficulties? Instead, the 'bully-boys' are sent round and charge to excess for the privilege. Disgraceful. Rest in peace Mr Miller. And to Mr Miller's family,I hope you fight this all the way

cameragirl says...
10:38am Fri 16 Jan 09

Poor Andy - I can't believe what I've just read.

I looked after him in hospital during his recent stay and he was such a lovely, charming man.

I am so upset to think of him being treated in this way.

Shame on all concerned. You should have this man's death on your consciences for a long time.

My condolences and very sincere sympathies to his family.

Robbie says...
12:07pm Fri 16 Jan 09

while his death is sad, and i feel for his family.

he should have paid his fine on time. and he should not have been speeding in the first place.

if the court had said, oh its ok your old we will let u off, what impression would that have given


Akki says...
12:10pm Fri 16 Jan 09

"Coroner Michael Singleton has ruled out an inquest, because tests had found Mr Miller died of natural causes as a result of heart problems, officials said. "

This man is the real killer in this case, he is legitimising the actions of the baliff, clearly the baliff gave the pensioner a heart attack by marching him to the town cash point, but the coroner thinks this is ok. Shame on Michael Singleton, murderer.

Condolences to the family.

Dogsbolloxs says...
12:13pm Fri 16 Jan 09

Whilst I cannot disagree with fettler, however insensitive the comment. The problem here is the SCUM bailiffs and the bully-boy and ILLEGAL tactics they employ. How many other pensioners, who have not died, have been bullied and physically escorted to cash-points to pay debts but not been reported in the press? a debt was registered at my address from previous occupants so I know first hand the tactics they employ, fortunately I know my rights and managed to sort them out.

Akki says...
12:22pm Fri 16 Jan 09

People who say he should have paid on time havnt read the article properly, we all make mistakes like driving over the speed limit sometimes, he was having problems making ends meet, he was still working as a cleaner at the age of 78, why the courts added on an extortionate £290 to the £60 for the ill pensioner shows the sickening state of this country.

samspence says...
12:37pm Fri 16 Jan 09

dosn,t this story make you proud to be british.get on with your tea parties mr straw .your a bit late to help the poor guy now!

The Lancs says...
1:45pm Fri 16 Jan 09

Shame on YOU 'fettler'. A common thief would be given more allowances and be allowed to run the court system ragged with payment of fines for REAL criminal offences. This man has made a mistake, hurt nobody, been ill and unable to pay the fine for whatever reason and then is frog-marched to his death by those who have a license to put the fear of god into normally law abiding citizens. Go and take your moral stance elsewhere you insensitive moron.

MJ Rover says...
3:10pm Fri 16 Jan 09

Whilst he may have done wrong initially by speeding, the fact that the family wrote to the courts explaining his ill health should have bought him some time, or at least given them other options - perhaps the family could have been given the opportunity to pay it on his behalf.

It's a shocking situation and very, very sad. Condolences to Mr Miller's family. Good luck in your search for answers.

RAyzer says...
3:18pm Fri 16 Jan 09

typical of labour and there scum bullying old folk,and giving immigrants and dole dossers freebies,this guy worked and couldnt afford it...

RAyzer says...
3:18pm Fri 16 Jan 09

typical of labour and there scum bullying old folk,and giving immigrants and dole dossers freebies,this guy worked and couldnt afford it...

Theo says...
3:44pm Fri 16 Jan 09

R.I.P. Andy.

brok says...
4:54pm Fri 16 Jan 09

Anyone reading this must be shocked at three things. Firstly the heavy handed tactics of a legal system that caused a death. Secondly, a coroner who makes no comment about the bullying tactics. Thirdly I just cannot believe the insensitivity of those who say "He should have paid".

We live in a police state system, the addition of nearly three hundred pounds in costs when a man has explained the fact that he was in hospital is something that should be chased all the way to European Court of Human rights.

The Bailiff system is wrong and should be banned, it is a private company exercising powers that should only be exercised by the government. No one should be forced to an ATM machine the action should be illegal. All I need is a fake ID and a clip board and I could make a fortune frightening money out of people, the system is evil in the extreme, thank you Tony Blair, (he was the one who sanctioned this type of action), soon to be the most hated Prime Minister in history.

RAyzer says...
5:48pm Fri 16 Jan 09

tony blair middle east peace envoy 2MILLION year..why we paying this and whats it do with us??2 million a year could get x amount of police and nurses in OUR OWN COUNTRY!!r.i.p to this poor bloke

workaholic says...
6:23pm Fri 16 Jan 09

I agree brok - a 500% rise in costs added to a £60 initial fine is a scandal! These bailiffs are scum!
(given a free hand to operate an extortion racket with the collusion of the court system!)

bye the way says...
6:58pm Fri 16 Jan 09

The magistrates and the bailiffs have actively contributed to the death of this poor old man.
They were informed about this gentleman's health problems, and yet they carried on with their Gestapo methods without thought or consideration.
I hope the family can find some recourse to legal action against these heartless cowards for this needless death.

andy1 says...
9:48pm Fri 16 Jan 09

Typical system that employs leeches called Bailiffs to do its dirty work. How any one can become one of these Saddos is beyond me. I wouldnt become a Bailiff if it was the last job on earth the ammount of lives they ruin is unbelievable. Bailiffs = SCUM OF THE EARTH. Thoughts go out to this elderly Gents Nearest and Dearest.

Akki says...
10:25pm Fri 16 Jan 09

Maybe this death wont be in vain, if an inquiry leads to an overhaul in this system.

phil8715 says...
10:45pm Fri 16 Jan 09

I was actually in town on that day and saw something going on outside the Bon Marche store. The court should be charged with corporate manslaughter. The Bailiff should be charged with MURDER. What a disgrace some of you are saying he should have paid his fine, he was confused and had memory loss. A 78 old man who was still working to make ends meet because he had money problems. Bailiffs are the scum of the earth and if one ever came to my door he would be met with a baseball bat.

ursulavasey says...
11:06pm Fri 16 Jan 09

I was in Accrington that day, and although I didn't directly witness what happened, I saw the emergency services arrive to treat Mr Miller. I knew nothing about the person concerned at the time, of course. Having read this article, I feel sickened by the actions of the bailiff, the debt court and the Coroner's Court. This form of legalised bullying and intimidation must be stopped by the government. There is no need to effectively frog-march a person to a cashpoint to secure the money owed, particularly as the court, who were pursuing him for the money owed, knew this man's medical history and, presumably, passed these details on to the appointed bailiffs. This heavy-handed attitude was completely un-called for, given Mr Miller's age and health condition. I hope that the bailiff has financial issues himself one day and the bailiffs that come to him show him the same "treatment" that he gave to Mr Miller.

My sympathies go to Mr Miller's family at this heartbreaking time. I never knew Andy Miller, or his family, but rest in peace, Andy. At least they can't get you any more.

soap opera says...
11:10pm Fri 16 Jan 09

you have to blame the blackpool court."I VOS ONLY FOLLOWING ORDERS"they will say.NOTHING TO DO WITH US GUV" will be the bailiff responce.adding £290 is a scandal.but it will all be forgot about by the establishment in a couple of weeks TILL THE NXT TIME

brok says...
12:33pm Sat 17 Jan 09

I have sent the following email, I also sent copies of this forum. Anyone is welcome to copy and paste it and send it to:popeg@parliament.
uk and to the Justice minister: info@bridgetprentic
emp.org.uk
Hon Greg Pope
House of Commons, London SW1A 0AA

Dear Sir,

I am sure you are aware of the circumstances surrounding the death of Mr Andrew Miller of Accrington.
“A PENSIONER collapsed and died from a heart attack after being taken to a cashpoint by a bailiff to pay an overdue speeding fine”. (Lancashire Telegraph).

I have pasted some of the correspondence received by the Telegraph to illustrate the horror this story has produced in the area.

When will this type of bailiff action be made illegal. Mr Miller who had been hospitalised at the time the fine remained unpaid was a victim of a system that should not exist in the modern world, certainly not in a post-modern Western society.

I am sure most people in the Accrington area will be anxious to hear your questions in the commons on this subject.

robrta1950 says...
8:20pm Sat 17 Jan 09

Disgraceful.
Councillors should hang their heads in shame.
Bully boys should not be employed as part of the debt recovery process.
Councils and other government agencies should refuse to recover debts via these strongarm tactics.

Totally says...
12:12pm Sun 18 Jan 09

Condolences to the family.

It is incredible that we live in a society where it is considered acceptable to pour public money into paying people to intimidate regular people for civil misdemeanours but do little to pursue criminal scum who leave hundreds of thousands outstanding in unpaid fines every year.

It is typical bureaucratic nonsense to go for the easy target to improve figures.

Once again decent people are paying to subsidise the low-lives and this time the price paid has been far too high.

Centaur says...
1:43pm Mon 19 Jan 09

The baliff and the coroner should be charged with culpable manslaughter.

Shameless!

Nelly. says...
7:59pm Mon 19 Jan 09

What a horrifying story. I can't belive it is legal for a bailiff to act in this way, no way should he have been able to take Mr Miller to a cash machine. Condolencest to Mr Miller's family.


PROBE: An investigation has been ordered into the death of Andy Miller CASH MACHINE: The cash machine site in Union Street, Accrington where the bailiff took Mr Miller, who collapsed

PROBE: An investigation has been ordered into the death of Andy Miller

CASH MACHINE: The cash machine site in Union Street, Accrington where the bailiff took Mr Miller, who collapsed



Most popular


Local Information

Enter your postcode, town or place name

House prices »   Schools »   Crime »   Hospitals »

Local Businesses